Most Europeans don’t like the EU. They don’t want to leave it, and they don’t want to destroy it. But they are offended by the busybody behavior of the Brussels bureaucracy as it interferes with their daily lives in their own countries. The last Polish government, headed by Opus Dei members, tried to get traction with the public opinion by attacking the EU and blaming it for Poland’s troubles. It didn’t work.
There are lots of ironies in the fire. Nations on the outside, Turkey, Georgia, Ukraine, Serbia want in. Once they make it, if they do, their citizens will be free to start hating. Several years ago, the European Commission adopted a constitution that would have made the EU a kind of super country, a sort of United States of Europe. It was required that it be adopted by all the countries. In many countries, governments, aware of the distaste for Brussels, prescribed a referendum. The constitution died aborning with vetoes from France and the Netherlands. There was something almost irrationally gleeful in this rejection — like we showed them, didn’t we?
So the governments of the nations decided that they would go in another direction. They approved a treaty at Lisbon in Portugal that saved much of the constitution, eliminated some of the aspects that everyone hated and tried to adjust to the addition of many new member states. On paper, the provisions seemed reasonable enough, though the government leaders and the pen pushers in Brussels didn’t “get” it. No one likes the EU. They suffer it like a visit to the dentist, but they don’t like it.
Most of the countries simply ratified the treaty in their parliaments. The fact that any one country could veto what seemed like an essential reform was not acceptable. However, Ireland agreed that it would submit the treaty to a referendum. Anyone who had any sense of Ireland’s propensity for being “agin it” — whatever “it” might be — would have known that the Lisbon treaty was dead on arrival. That all the political parties, except Sinn Fein supported it, along with all the commercial groups, and the whole Irish establishment only made rejection more inevitable. It was a way of getting even not only with Brussels but also with their own leaders. We sure showed them, didn’t we? Let them go get us a better deal. What the better deal would be is not clear. But it is clear that any attempt to improve the structure or the power of the EU will be slapped down by the “plain people of Ireland.”
I personally don’t think that Ireland belongs in the EU because I don’t think they really are Europeans.
Rather they should be part of some sort of “middle Atlantic” group as they talked about some years ago. But if they want to pretend that they are Europeans like the French or the Germans or the Dutch or the Poles, when they patently are not, then let them think that they are.
The leaders of the European countries were upset. After all we’ve done for Ireland, they’re ungrateful so and sos.
The German foreign minister, a socialist, suggested that it might be necessary to go on without Ireland.
The 54 percent of the Irish who voted against the treaty are very proud of themselves. They showed them! Besides, they’re voting for all the people in the EU who didn’t get a chance to vote.
It is, as they would say, great craic (which means fun).



1 user commented in " Caught between a shamrock and a hard place "
Follow-up comment rss or Leave a TrackbackDear Father Greeley,
It doesn’t surprise me that Ireland doesn’t want to be homogenized into the EU. Apparently none of the countries in the EU want to give up their national identities for the common good (so to speak).
The EU seems to have been very good for Ireland; those good people finally have a little prosperity! In the New York area many of our young illegal Irish immigrants have returned to the “old sod” because jobs are available for them. Good for them!!!! Fine people, the Irish!!!
What is an European anyway? It’s true that Ireland is not part of the European continent and therefore they are not really European (the same can be said for the UK); however the countries that do make up the European continent are just as dissimilar to each-other as Ireland is to them. The French are certainly nothing like the Germans; how about the Spanish, the Italians, the Dutch etc? The differences between the countries of Europe (culturally, economically, religiously )has been both the beauty and the curse of its peoples. The lack of understanding and cooperation between the European countries has been the cause of at least 2 serious wars that I can recall from our last century. I am always fond of saying: The Europeans, left to their own devices, will go to war with each-other sooner or later.
So, all the countries want the economic advantage that the EU gives them without giving up any of their own national character. Quite understandable in light of human nature!
The French likely think that everyone in Europe should be like them likewise the Germans and the English. I don’t think that the Irish are pompous enough to think that everyone should be like the Irish however they do know that they don’t want to be German, French or (dare I say) English.